Discover The Difference

See how our premium meat and seafood delivery service stacks up against the competition!

hero imagehero image

ButcherBox vs Others

See how ButcherBox compares against other meat delivery services

butcherbox logo
Good Chop
Good Ranchers
Omaha Steaks
100% Grass-fed beef across all cuts
Black option
Red option
Red option
Red option
Pasture-raised, Grain-finished
beef
Black option
Black option
Black option
Wrong option
Animals are never confined to
a feedlot
Black option
Red option
Red option
Red option
B-corp certified
Black option
Red option
Red option
Red option
All products are free of antibiotics
and added hormones
Black option
Wrong option
Black option
Wrong option
All products are third-party
animal welfare certified
Black option
Red option
Red option
Red option
Shipping cost
Free
$9.99
Free
$19.99
Pricing*
$10.50 - $15 /lb
$10.64 -
$18.43 /lb
$15.28 -
$17.85 /lb
$20.52 /lb
LIMITED TIME OFFER! GET FREE PROTEIN
CHOOSE BUTCHERBOX

*All pricing effective as of 9/17/2025 and are based on the following: ButcherBox's Custom subscription box, Good Chop's Medium subscription box, Good Ranchers' Essentials Box (subscription and non- subscription), and Omaha Steak's All Protein Pack subscription box. ButcherBox pricing includes free protein for 12 months with the value of up to $422^

Join 400,000 ButcherBox members

“Better cuts than most of the stores around me for about the same price or cheaper. Love the quality and value; the convenience is just an added bonus. Highly recommend”

- PAUL